Reply to comment

The BMI Project

Fat-acceptance activist/blogger Kate Harding has assembled a collection of photographs to illustrate "how ridiculous the BMI really is." Each photo title states the person's BMI status (underweight, normal, obese, and morbidly obese), and the range of representations is both shocking and breathtaking. My favorite is Moxie, the morbidly obese cat with a BMI of 58.6.

obese cat

What I really love about this collection is that not only does it challenge the arbitrary categorizations of what it means to be "normal" or "morbidly obese" (one woman in that painful category is pictured at a Tai Chi tournament in Japan), but it also challenges the individual's conceptions of what those categories represent. For example, a "normal" individual may actually look "underweight," while many of the "obese" (such a loaded term) women are, to put it bluntly, smokin' hot. And then there is Shauna Marsh Reid, who has lost fully half of her body weight, going from 352 pounds to 176, extensively documented here, yet still falls under the BMI category of "overweight." Despite the fact that she is healthier than she has ever been in her life, the lack of context inherent to the BMI works to condemn her as still somehow unacceptable.

Reply

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
7 + 8 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Your contribution to the blog: Please Read Before Posting

The viz. blog is a forum for exploring the visual through identifying the connections between theory, rhetorical practice, popular culture, and the classroom. Keeping with this mission, comments on the blog should further discussion in the viz. community by extending (or critiquing) existing analysis, adding new analysis, providing interesting and relevant examples, or by making connections between that topic and theory, rhetoric, culture, or pedagogy. Trolling, spam, and any other messages not related to this purpose will be deleted immediately.

Comments by anonymous users will be added to a moderation queue and examined for their relevance before publication. Authenticated users may post comments without moderation, but if those comments do not fit the above description they may be deleted.

Recent comments